I am playing in a keeper league. Which of these players are worth keeping?

I have Mauer, Ichiro, Jeter, Zimmerman, and Sizemore. It is a ten team league, and our stats are H,R,HR,RBI,SB, OBP,K,W, SV,ERA,WHIP,K/9. Each person I save costs me one draft. So if I keep three, my first draft is in the fourth round. I can keep up to six, but the rest aren't worth keeping at all, like Lance Berkman, Jose Lopez, Nick Markakis and Torii Hunter and Nate McLouth(I already have Ichiro), Trevor Hoffman, and John Lackey. I'm thinking about ditching Jeter and going with Mauer, Ichiro, Zimmerman and Sizemore. Its a long-term league so Zimmerman and Mauer are going to be awesome/trade bait. Sizemore should be good. Jeter is getting old, though, but is still batting in front of some nasty power. Who should I save?